Renzi Court Decision

From Talking Points Memo: Susan Crabtree | June 23, 2011,  2:08PM – The 9th Circuit Court of Appeals has firmly rejected former Rep. Rick Renzi’s (R-AZ) claim that Constitutional protections granted to members of Congress prevented him from having to defend himself from charges that he used his position to enrich himself in a land deal.

The court’s decision on Thursday strikes a debilitating blow to federal lawmakers’ broad claims of immunity from prosecution on anything dealing with legislative activity. If Renzi appeals, it also could set up a Supreme Court showdown over exactly what level of protection from investigation and prosecution the Constitution provides members of Congress.

In recent years, several members of Congress, with the support of House Democratic and Republican leadership and the House general counsel, have tried to wrap themselves in the Speech or Debate clause of the Constitution in order to bar the Justice Department from gaining access to evidence on their Congressional computers or in their offices.

The clause was written to protect the legislative branch from unwarranted intrusion by the executive, but watchdogs and some legal scholars have argued that it has become a way for lawmakers to try to protect themselves from being thoroughly investigated for charges of corruption and unethical behavior.

The case against Renzi stems from his efforts his efforts to force a private company to buy land from his business partner as part of a land exchange that required his approval as a member of the House Natural Resources Committee.

In its decision, the 9th Circuit determined that negotiations regarding future legislation are not legislative activity protected by the Speech or Debate Clause. Similarly, the court decided that documents and correspondence related to those negotiations are not protected.

The Court upheld Renzi’s indictment even though some protected material was shown to the grand jury, ruling that because those documents were not the basis for the indictment, they did not constitute a violation of Renzi’s Constitutional protections.

The court also declined to follow the D.C. Circuit Court’s decision in Rayburn House Office Building case involving the FBI raid of ex-Rep. William Jefferson’s (D-LA) Capitol Hill office. In that case, House Democrats and Republicans stepped in to condemn the unprecedented raid, filed suit on Jefferson’s behalf, and the D.C. Circuit eventually ruled that the Speech and Debate clause precluded the review any documents related to legislative acts that were seized during the FBI raid.

Even though that ruling hurt the prosecutor’s case, Jefferson was still found guilty on multiple corruption charges.

Further, in the Renzi case, the appeals court found that the Speech and Debate clause does not prevent the executive branch from even examining legislative material.

Citizens For Responsibility and Ethics in Washington filed an amicus brief in the Renzi case supporting the government’s position that the Speech or Debate Clause did not preclude the prosecution of Rep. Renzi. Melanie Sloan, the group’s executive director, applauded the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals decision.

“…The Speech or Debate Clause was never intended to turn legislators into ‘super-citizens immune from criminal responsibility,'” she said in a statement. “Happily, the Court soundly rejected Rayburn, putting legislators on notice that the 9th Circuit at least will not protect them should they engage in bribery or extortion.”



About freemark1021
I am an anachocapitalist.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Karl Dickey's Blog

politics, cigars, general aviation, business, finance and personal development

Palm Beach Free Press

your freedom-focused news source

Real Currencies

Supporting People and the Commonwealth and resisting the Money Power by defeating Usury

Iraq Currency Watch

This blog is dedicated to the Iraqi Dinar


Res ipsa loquitur ("The thing itself speaks")


An online Journal by Bill Buppert devoted to the total abolition of slavery and the State.

Watts Up With That?

The world's most viewed site on global warming and climate change


...integrating Christian faith and knowledge in the public square

Adask's law

The Profit of Injustice

Radical Agenda

Common Sense Extremism

Real Science

"Science is the belief in the ignorance of the experts" - Richard Feynman

Laser Hacker Alternative Energy

Alternative projects, inventions, experiments and DIY projects

Christopher Cantwell

Radical Agenda

Bruce Krasting

My Take on Financial Events


At Your Service

Mind Control in America BLOG

Renee Pittman Books... an in depth look into historic and ongoing development programs, and use of highly advanced psycho-physical, psychological electronic mind invasive technology, using extremely low frequency radio waves and microwaves designed for covert, mass and social population control, manipulation and influence, on individuals, groups and large populations, legalized for nonconsensual military and law enforcement testing operations post 9/11. ***************************************************************************************************************** NOTE: These blogs were expertly edited and proofread before publishing. However, as interests grows on these specific topics, the agency monitoring the author and other whistleblower efforts, logically hope to keep this information hidden from the public. As a result, these blogs are being accessed repeatedly and are strategically being tampered with. This is being done by cleverly inserting typographical, punctuation and misspelled words. This is an obvious hope to plant a negative impression that the author is illiterate and also as a hope to turn people off to the information held within. Get the picture? Our admin team continues to catch and make corrections. **************************************************************************************************************** The science nonfiction DOCUMENTARY / DOCUDRAMA THRILLER depicting the FACTUAL use of patented microwave technology designed to create the beamed "Hearing Voices Effect" entitled "MIND CONTROL: SCHIZOPHRENIC HIGH TECH FRAUD" is available on Amazon.

Memory Hole

Reflections on Media and Politics | © Memory Hole Blog / James F. Tracy 2012-2016

Exposing Faux Capitalism

to the dismay of the Federal Reserve and other faux capitalists

%d bloggers like this: